I make no bones about it: I hate pumpkin beer. That doesn’t mean pumpkin beer deserves abolition, I personally just do not like pumpkin beer. That aside, I’ve come to realize I am truly a beer savant and felt it my duty to inform the masses that I discovered the world’s greatest pumpkin beer. Since the denouement of any literary work hardly belongs in the first paragraph (even in such an erudite form as a blog) you’ll have to read on through some context to discover what beer my discerning tongue has established as world class.
The story begins with me tearing off 3500 square feet of shingles. Roofing. Horrific. But unfortunately, this world demands capital for survival, and having lost my job, regarding capital, I found myself lacking in that department. So when the opportunity came to make a few shingles doing “handyman work” while I wait to land my dream job, I leaped at the opportunity, even though it meant (a frequent victim of acrophobia) ascending Babel.
I worked hard. Nearly 12 hours a day working muscles I didn’t know existed, not drinking an brew at night, and dreading the next day paid off unexpectedly. The last day at the job, as I was cleaning up in the evening, the homeowner came up to me and said, “Young man, are you married.”
“Yes sir, I replied”
He suddenly placed a $1o0 bill in my hand and said, “I’ve been watching you work…you’re a hard worker, take your wife out to dinner.”
To be honest, I nearly shat myself. I said thank you and pocketed the small fortune. At the first instant of receiving the gift, I thought, “Sweet! I can apply this to my mortgage!” But after some thinking, I realized that I really should take my sweet wife out to dinner. With five kids and floss string budget, it has been months since we’ve indulged in some alone time. So we headed out to downtown Kansas City that coming Friday.
At “The Beer Kitchen” I threw up in mouth a little when I saw that a bottle of Monstre Rouge cost $36 and a 6 ounce pour of Brother Thelonius would run me $7. Whatever. This was a special night. I ordered some forgettable French beer, a Brother Thelonius, and a burger. My wife did the same. It was good, and we still had a little bit of that $100 left, and the night was young. I wanted a bottle of some Jolly Pumkin, but didn’t want to spend $25 on it, knowing that back in Ohio I could pick it up for $10. So we paid our waiter and headed across the street to the Foundry.
Having never been there, I wasn’t sure what the beer menu would offer. The place was swarming with tragic hipsters–typically a sign that good beer is around, but I’ve noticed that ever nook cranny of Kansas City seems to be crawling with tragic hipsters. When I opened the beer menu and saw Jolly Pumpkin tap I think I giggled. When I saw that a full 6 ounce pour was only $6, I think I slipped into hysterics…until I saw that it was La Parcela, Jolly Pumpkin’s tribute to the wacky weird of Pumpkin Ales. This is one of the few Jolly Pumpkin beers I’ve not tried.
Talk about a rock and a hard place: Hate pumpkin beer, love Jolly Pumpkin, In KC, missing home a bit, hipsters tragic mustache at the next table is creepy…yeah, I ordered it.
It was good. Great. It surpassed every every other beer in the category. In fact, the pumpkin flavor was so peripheral, that it didn’t distract from that fact that what I was drinking was actually beer. The bretty sourness worked so well with the spicy nature of the ale. There’s no need to write an excessive review of the brew. The world’s best pumpkin beer was just good, and it not only made some coveted alone time with my wife that much better, it made the hours on the roof, the sunburn, and the blisters on my hands worth it.
Your post was terrific, Nate. The writing was great. The ideas were great. The story about your struggle is great. I always enjoy reading posts, mine included, that are full of pathos and an actually good pumpkin ale.
I feel your pain at roofing. I know that type of work all too well and my heart goes out to men who labor like that.
[Reply]
Fun. But you might enjoy Smashed Pumpkin if you ran over it. Er, across it. My take here: https://bit.ly/c3nQnA
[Reply]
Good stuff! I especially love the “forgettable French beer” part.
Never underestimate the kindness of people. It always seems to come around when we least expect it. I love hearing how that sort of kindness ends up with a cool story to boot.
And kudos on taking your wife out to dinner! They are the rock that helps keep us sane in turbulent times.
[Reply]
Cool post, it really sounded like a great night. I too detest the pumpkin beer, but I set out to try to find one I liked. I got DFH’s Punkin, Shipyard’s Pumpkinhead, Southern Tier’s Pumking, and Heavy Sea’s Great-er Pumpkin. The only one I didn’t hate was the last one, and that’s because the boubon-barrel aging cancelled out all of the nasty stuff. I haven’t had Jolly Pumpkin’s yet, but I’ll try to find it next year. I also hear good things about Schlafly’s.
[Reply]
Sounds unique. A pumpkin brew that is also sour. Probably saved it for you. Glad you are getting a little work, and I too am glad you took your wife out to dinner. This is what that money was meant for, and I’m a strong believer that everything happens for a reason. Don’t tempt fate. If the old guy said take your wife out, that is what you needed to do. I’m glad you did so. You two probably got more from that than the 100 towards the mortgage.
Great story.
[Reply]
Loved the story Nate. You did a great job of what you guys have often talked about on here – adding context to a beer review. I really think that adds more than a long list of tasting notes.
And how ’bout that, a pumpkin beer convert! Brett has that effect. It can really take a beer from good to great if used correctly.
Cheers guys.
[Reply]
Loved the post and I share your non-affinity for the pumpkin beer, for me it is all things pumpkin. I love the phrase “hipster tragic mustache” – it sums up nicely the reason I shave every other day. I hope your situation turns around.
[Reply]
Great story Nate. Pumpkin beers are mostly horrible, but its cool to have at least one that you really like. Tragic hipsters. Too funny!
[Reply]
Great read Nate, although I had to use a dictionary twice in the first paragraph! I hope your situation turns around, until then keep on keeping on.
There are two kinds of beer I avoid like the plague, pumpkin beer and ginger beers. Although I did have the Jolly Pumpkin Biere de Goord, and it was a decent beer, nice bretty’ness to the beer, but the pumpkin was not noticeable and turned out to be a Typical Jolly Pumpkin Brett beer. (that is a good thing).
Take care my friend!
[Reply]
beer_scientist Reply:
October 29th, 2010 at 5:26 pm
We love making people learn new words. I guess you didn’t know that this blog is a front for people to gain more verbal skills….in all seriousness, I avoid the pumpkin beers too.
[Reply]
What about Dogfish Head Punkin Ale..
[Reply]
I personally think it’s a good beer…we’ll have to see what Nate says.
[Reply]
I know this is an old post. Even so, I can’t help but ask: why should people take your word that this is the “World’s best pumpkin beer”, when you say you hate (or hated) pumpkin beer. Maybe there is a little too much rhetoric surrounding your praise of this beer. This was still an interesting read.
[Reply]
nate Reply:
September 19th, 2011 at 7:32 am
Hey Beerfox,
This beer didn’t taste like pumpkin, a flavor i don’t enjoy in or outside of beer. That being said, nobody needs to take my word for anything, especially if they love pumpkin so much they bathe in it.
Your absolutely right, this post was intentionally rhetoric loaded.
The term “World’s Best Pumpkin Beer” is so subjective (like beer) it probably only applies to me. Did you try the beer? Let me know what you think. Thanks for swinging by!
[Reply]