One hit wonders are not limited to the music industry. Aha is to 80′s pop as Primo is to Beer fads.
Sure, plenty of breweries have one or two slam dunk beers that everyone can agree, but what really puts them on the map?
There are two reasons I have been considering this: First, I just visited Three FLoyds Brewery, and walked away very impressed, not only with there outstanding lineup of beer, but with the company in general. Second, I recently purchased a sampler pack (great litmus test for quality consistency in a brewery) from Mendicino brewery and unfortunately had to choke down nearly every beer in the pack. As drank Medicino’s beer, I thought, “how do these guys manage to stay in business?
A few thoughts come to mind…
As I said before, a great brewery puts out a consistent line up of great beers. I think of Dogfish head. Their Raison D’ Etre exhibits the same quality as their 120 Minute IPA, even though they fall in different categories. You don’t have to like every variety, but the quality is apparent.
Breweries are able to balance Risk and Reward. In doing so, they create new market space. Everyone else is whipping out mild batches of IPA bittered up with cascade hops…do you really think we need another brewery touting this as their flagship beer? If so, there will be dehibilitating and tiring competion going on.
Breweries that find a way to make themselves desired succeed. I guess this would be innovative marketing. Dark Lord Day is the perfect example. Let’s face it, Russian Imperial Stout is not a typical cult favorite. But the Three Floyds, by opening up this beer for sale only once a year at their brewery, bypass commercial resale and create a sort esoteric nature for their brewery. You have to have a golden ticket–know the secret handshake–just to taste this goodness. People want what is hard to come by.
Admittedly, I’ve just scratched the surface, and may be way off. After all, America’s most drinkable beer will most likely never find it’s way on to this site!
So I’m curious…why do you love and respect your favorite breweries? And how were you offended by breweries that you may find apalling? As two guys who would love to open a brewery someday, we need some feedback!
I can tell you that I’d rather fail miserably with quality than flourish with mediocrity.
[Reply]
Me too. But if someone fails with quality, other important factors were overlooked. Like a sexy mascot.
[Reply]
3 words. Drink-a-bility
I think its the same reason any company lives or dies. The quality of its people, the love for making beer (or whatever) respect for the customers – maybe even over-delivering on expectations. Some brewers have it, others don’t.
[Reply]
Scott…you said “the quality of its people.” I think that’s spot on.
[Reply]
Deschutes would be my favorite brewery. Their year-round brews are all excellent. Black Butte Porter and Mirror Pond Pale Ale are probably their most popular offerings. Their seasonals and specialty brews are fantastic as well. I need to get my hands on some Cinder Cone Red. Each beer is hopped appropriately to style, and each beer is full of body. As a northwest brewery, they tend to focus on local ingredients, which enhances freshness. Quality, quality, quality. Consistency, consistency, consistency.
Harshness in a beer turns me off. It can be from the more resiny hops, or it can be over-carbonated, or the combo of high hops with harsh malts. Sam Adams’ regular line-up comes to mind. I appreciate their role in forging ahead in the craft brewing industry, but I just won’t buy their product. Don’t confuse this with hop-bombs or Russian Imperial Stouts, as there are many examples of both that I find delicious.
I, too, would like to start a brewery some day. Imagine that…
[Reply]
I think we are finding some of our people for the future Nate. Who knows what the future holds for us, guys? I know that I’m going to do all that I can to make it happen. I’ve only had a couple of Deschutes things but I’m about to get some Abyss from a guy…we’ll see what happens.
[Reply]
I agree Scott. I want to be one of the good ones.
[Reply]
I think its rad you want to start a brewery big Tex…how long has the idea been on your radar?
[Reply]
re: Starting a brewery… It’s been on my mind off and on for a few years. However, I’m torn. Do it here in WA, or move my family back to TX to do it. Or… be like Red Hook and have a couple brewery locations.
Truthfully, I’m still working on my technique and recipes. Funding is another issue. We’ll see.
[Reply]
I know what you mean on all accounts…it’s tough, especially the funding.
[Reply]
I agree with you on Mendicino there Nate. Of the ones I have they are just not that good.
[Reply]
In thinking about location, you check into tax and alcohol laws. For example, starting a brewery here in ohio would be sill because of the 12% cap on malt beverages. I think Mike and I both would want to put out at least one extreme beer, if even one batch a year. Ohio says no.
Funding…I think about this one all the time. Commercial loans are a nightmare. Did you know that in most commercial loans a lendor has every right to demand total payment at any given point, despite payment schedule? I have a buddy feel this pain as the bank called his note early (not in full but, partial…but it was 30K he didn’t have). that’s why i would like to go private investor.
[Reply]
[...] have been under the impression for some time, that success in business requires more than just a great product. The beer industry is no exception. Besides all the obvious ingredients to success (sell-ability, [...]