Today I watched Spain lose to the Swiss. Keep in mind that Spain is widely considered the favorite to win the World Cup. Many of the learned soccer experts, FIFA, and fans assume that certain teams will win or be great in the World Cup. Of course, I’m not saying it’s unfair to expect teams like Brazil or Germany to almost always do well, but it is interesting to see who actually excels and who doesn’t.
I almost always expect good performances by certain breweries. Dogfish Head, The Lost Abbey, and a few others are almost always going to make a beer I enjoy. Sometimes the beer is profound, other times it’s pretty good, occasionally I’ll get a dud, which is a real rarity. Other breweries are like the U.S. soccer team; they are major hit and miss ventures. The beer may be good or the beer may be bad, but they don’t seem ever to be great. Still other breweries are like North Korea. They get no respect and likely will not be good in the foreseeable future. But some beers are like the Swiss. You don’t expect a lot, but they surprise you.
Just like the supposed beer experts, the beer community, and particular brewery fans, people can be totally wrong in their assessment of a brewery. One particular topic that interests me is the look of a bottle. I bet many of us have been guilty (or I should at least say we could be accused) of buying a beer based on looks. But as teams like the Swiss and a myriad of beers prove, you can’t always judge a book by its cover. I needed to remind myself of the fact that sometimes you can’t trust the experts or the outside of the bottle. Like mom said, it’s what’s inside that counts. What beers have surprised you?
I like the comparison to soccer. There are totally those breweries out there that always up out a quality beer and others that really seem to struggle. I really enjoyed Spoetzl Brewery 101 which was a Czech Style Pils and I though it was very well done. I haven’t really enjoyed a lot of their beers, but this one hit the spot.
[Reply]
beer_scientist Reply:
June 16th, 2010 at 2:06 pm
Nate,
Thanks for stopping by and I’m glad you like the comparison. Sometimes they work well and sometimes they’re a stretch. I can agree about the brewery you’ve mentioned…not a lot of great stuff but sometimes there’s a surprise.
[Reply]
HA! I was the king of that. I used to get completely sucked in by the design on the label, now i’m a sucker for “Bourbon Barrel”, “Barrel Aged”, or “Wild” this “Sour” thats on the label. Same problem just a different team. The best part about it, I’m perfectly fine with that. I want to buy beer not because it is the latest great shit, but because I’ve really been liking those types/styles of beers. But if Brazil(Dogfish Head) came out with a Barrel aged Sour I’d be right there to get it!
[Reply]
It seems your perv-stache is coming in nicely!
I’d agree, your comparison works well and makes a good point. In my case I haven’t yet tried most breweries full lineups, so its hard for me to say I’ve found a gem beer amongst the average. I suppose in time I’ll learn more, but I do try to keep the looks thing in mind when picking a beer I haven’t tried before.
I guess the beer that most surprised me recently was Avery’s Hog Heaven. I bought it on a whim. I never had anything from Avery, nor have I ever had a barley wine prior to that. The name of the beer, along with the flying pigs on the label said ‘ooooh risky beer’ I had no idea what it was going to be like, but I really enjoyed it and look forward to trying other Avery beers now.
[Reply]
I have to say, Peter, I’d by a DFH sour also. I’m fine with being suckered in by the occasional style. I’m a sucker for the barreled stuff, too. I just like grabbing something I normally wouldn’t and getting myself out of the mindset of label association.
Scott, I like Avery and I’ve really enjoyed the barrel stuff. Thanks for giving a case-in-point about just going on a limb sometimes.
[Reply]
I had one just the other night. Hale’s Supergoose IPA. The label is completely repelling, and stupid. It has a picture of a Meerkat in a cape on the label. Almost as dumb as that Salt Lake City Brew that had a ram breathing fire in downtown SLC on the label. But the brew was impressive. I haven’t had Pliney, but I’d love to do a throw down between the two. I’d put the Hales up against just about any contender.
[Reply]
Don,
It’s nice to see some people venturing out of the label thing. I admit that I’ve bought on label, name, or other aspects before but I think of some that I’ve bought just to try. Old Leg Humper is a good example of one that I’ve ventured to try and liked. I don’t care for the name or label but I really enjoyed the beer. I’d love to see the beer you mentioned against Pliny, especially because I don’t think it deserves the sort of accolades it gets. Thanks for sharing a bit
[Reply]