We recently got Consecration from Russian River at the Whole Foods on Arroyo Parkway in Pasadena. It was another one of those beers you hear about and is hyped to extreme levels. I always give beers like this a try to see if their worth the level of fame attached to them. I suppose I don’t have to mention that I was somewhat skeptical, or at least cautious, about the beer.
When I looked at the $21.99 bottle of beer on the shelf, I noticed that four strains of bacteria were used in it. In fact, it’s the same mix as WLP 655 that I’ve used in a couple recent brews; Lactobactillus, Pediococcus, Saccharomyces, and Bretts were all a part of the beer. The first two are especially known for the production of lactic acid. What did that mean? Sour ale for sure. So far, so good. I’m a fan of a good sour ale. The third is simply an ale yeast, whose name will remain anonymous because the brewers and yeast company chose to do so. The Bretts are known for their funk, which can often take quite a bit of time to develop, a great reason for me to pick up a second bottle. Top it all off with currants. On to the beer.
The Pour: When I poured Consecration, I noted its reddish-brown body that seemed to resemble a nicely steeped tea. A fairly small amount of head retention kept the semi-active body very noticeable, as there was no creamy top at which to look. From the pour, I would have guessed that was a Flemish Brown/Red styled sour.
The Nose: Being 10% ABV, Consecration had a sturdy but not overbearing alcohol hotness on the nose. The oak tones gave the vague perception of a distilled spirit, while sour cherry (here are the currants) tones along with a touch of smokiness bled out some almost kriek lambic qualities. The nose was also reminiscent of a Flemish Brown such as the classic Rodenbach. Although not dripping with sweetness, the beer was firmly fruity, redolent of pineapple as the beer warmed.
The Taste: As all signs pointed, this selection drank like a strong Flemish Brown sour. Surprisingly, the alcohol was not overly hot, but there was a bourbon quality lent from the oak and alcohol. A medium mouth-feel helped to balance out the dry finish. And although true for the nose, there was little remaining sweetness to the brew on the taste. However, the sour red cherry and pineapple fruits could have been interpretated as such. Those sour currants mixed with that lactic acid produced proved to be a wonderful pucker.
Overall, I think this a terrific beer. It is everything that a good sour ought to be. It puckers, it tingles, it excites. In fact, a guy I work with shared the price of the bottle with me, and we drank it together. He’d never had a sour before and he was blown away. He simply kept exclaiming that he didn’t know beer could be like this. It was rewarding to hear him say that I helped open his eyes to a whole new world of beer. Among the everyday brews that flood the market, this may be an epiphany. It’s my favorite Russian River beer thus far (yes, more than Pliny).
Mike’s Rating:
Overall Satisfaction: 



Among other Sours: 



Rating: 





Wow. I’ve never had a sour either (like your friend @ work). I don’t think we get that out here in Jersey, but maybe my Whole Foods will surprise me again!
[Reply]
Maybe. You really should try a sour or two. They are truly a pleasure.
[Reply]
I’ve had one sour beer that tasted like the sweat from fermented gym socks! Not a good example of the genre I suppose. I’d like to try something that was a sour and well crafted. I’ll look for this brew at my local beer store.
[Reply]
Don, I’m not going to ask how you know what fermented sweat tastes like, but the imagery is quite the opposite that which Michael describes! To avoid such horrors, Michael, can you recommend another that’s good?
[Reply]
@Scott, Curvee Rene. Most anything by Cantillion. Mikeller’s It’s Alright. Anything by Haansen’s of Dworp. Saison Rue by the Bruery (this is more of a beginners sour). Also, St. Louis Fond is a good one.
@Don. Sweaty gym socks, horse blanket, corn chips are all flavors and aromas that I’ve heard and said. They do take a bit of acclimation. Sours are terrific if you’ve developed a taste. Some people, like David, love them immediately. Good luck on finding some tasty ones.
[Reply]
Thanks Michael. I’ll see what’s findable and see if I can try one from that list.
[Reply]
I have a couple bottles of this have yet to open it because it is very hard for me to get in Jersey. Can’t wait though, I love, love, love, love sours. In fact I’m brewing one now that is getting pretty sour after 3months in the secondary.
@scott, we get lots of sours, at least funky beers here. Captain Lawrence makes a bunch, Jolly pumpkin, Cantillion, Del Borge and more. Go talk to Kevin at the Liquor Outlet, he can help you out there.
[Reply]
It’s not exactly easy to get it here in Cali, so I can feel what you mean in Jersey. I love sours, too. I’ve got one that’s coming up on 4 months old, an ESB that I used a sour mix in secondary, a small beer that has sour yeast, a valentines chocolate sour and another sour as well. I guess you could say I’ve gone a little wild (pun intended) on it. As far as my other Consecrator, it’s got a couple years until it sees my lips.
[Reply]
@SimplyBeer – thanks for the reccos on the sour beer. I’ve been curious to give them a shot, I think I saw the Jolly Pumpkin @ Whole Foods that you reviewed not too long ago. Maybe I’ll give it a go!
[Reply]
@scott Let me know if you can’t find anything, We’ll brew some beer at my house and break out some wild ales. I have a whole cellar full of some crazy sours.
[Reply]
TNX Peter – I think I might be a bit like a kid in a candy shop @ your place! (I may never leave either!)
[Reply]